Expensive German Plastic: The Generations of Heckler & Koch

I will not delve into what to make of this rather anomalous election, this time A LOT worse than better. It is like Biden 2020 all over again: something is off about the numbers driving the supposed results, but it once again may be something that has to be endured as fait accompli for a cycle anyway and responded to accordingly in the next. This makes it all the more cause to assert our fundamental freedom, denying the Leftist powermongers the opportunity to exploit their ill-gotten gains, because after 250 years of our shining liberty we know this week does not reflect who we are as Americans.
Part of what has made America so strong is adopting the best ideas and designs from all over the world. This goes particularly for the realm of arms: while Brown Bess muskets and other "acquired" British arms were the closest it got to standard issue for the nascent Continental Army, once the French supplied the .69 caliber Charleville en masse its more reinforced build & superior ballistics were favored by General Washington. Once mass production of American arms began at Springfield Armory (Massachusetts) and Harpers Ferry (Virginia), the first models essentially cloned the Charleville and .69 remained the standard chambering all the way to the end of the smoothbore line, the M1848 (used extensively in the Civil War).
The turn of the century became an outreach time for the US military. America's first .30 caliber rifle was an adaptation of the Norwegian Krag–Jørgensen, the alternative adopted by the Navy & Marines a 6mm by Briton James Paris Lee (who also developed the Lee-Enfield series which was standard British issue in the first half of the 20th century). In the realm of general issue pistols America was among the earliest to transition from revolvers to autoloaders (Switzerland was the first, adopting the German-made Borchardt C93 before quickly replacing it with the more enduring Luger), among the contestants ultimately losing to John Moses Browning's Colt M1911 a .45 caliber variant of the Luger.
Save for the Beretta M9, officially adopted for cost reasons (despite the SIG Sauer P226 barely eking out the win on raw effectiveness) but ostensibly to kiss up to Italy at a vital point in the Cold War, American-designed arms were standard issue throughout the 20th century while German designs were consistently favored for special issue. MACV-SOG used the silenced Walther PPK for close-range wet work, the MP5 submachine gun became THE symbol of special operations, wherever the Beretta M9 was less-suitable it was a SIG Sauer in the holster, then in the 21st century both pistols and rifles by SIG Sauer and Heckler & Koch graduated to standard issue. Today it is SIG Sauer dominating the standard issue realm, while the more selective USMC and USSOCOM most gravitated towards variants of the HK416.
Origins
Heckler & Koch, a name leaving out its 3rd co-founder Alex Seidel (although, granted: it would not have the same ring to it), rose from the post-WWII ashes of Mauser. Immediately succeeding that legacy, they developed the roller-delayed G3 rifle from the Spanish CETME (itself derived from German StG 45 plans taken to Spain at the end of the war) which today remains the most enduring of the battle rifles made for Free World militaries in the Cold War (the Belgian FN FAL was adopted more but today has been almost completely supplanted). After that first success they shifted to a more special-use focus, by far the most famous being the MP5 which adapted the same operating mechanism as the G3. Long arms from H&K have since then had their ups (HK416) and downs (G36) but continue trucking along; their line of pistols, on the other hand, have a rather more interesting story over the decades.

H&K is the direct successor to Mauser, thus their first pistol, the HK4, derived from the Mauser HSc. But rather than a direct derivative, the HK4 was first of the creative approach that would define the company for years to come, called the HK4 because of its capability to be rechambered among 4 calibers (.22 LR, .25 ACP, .32 ACP, .380 ACP) in seconds by switching barrels and magazines. That being its only standout feature, it was unexceptional otherwise but adopted by some police agencies nonetheless.

A following design, the VP70, had such an out-of-this-world look it got used as a prop in science fiction films. It was the first striker-fired, polymer-framed pistol ever produced (beating Glock by a full decade), and was geared towards special use by incorporating select-fire capability in attached stock configuration. Such then-standout features proved too far ahead of their time for 1970, and the VP70 being ergonomically unwieldy in either configuration meant it would be the company's first notable failure.

Designed alongside the VP70 (actually produced first, in 1969), the P9[S] went in a more enduring direction. A fixed (non-Browning) barrel design regulated 9x19mm pressures by incorporating a delayed blowback mechanism (like the Czech CZ 52 in 7.62x25) which increased production costs but granted reliability and versatility like virtually nothing else back then. This capability enabled the P9 to become the first H&K pistol adopted for both police and special military use.

The incorporated roller-delay mechanism reached full fruition in what is not only hands-down the most sophisticated pistol made by H&K but the what continues to stand as the most sophisticated (thus most expensive) pistol ever made. Developed in response to the Munich Massacre that had highlighted the inadequacy of the then-standard Walther PPs, the P7 joined the lineup alongside the Walther P5 (last of the P38 derivatives) and SIG Sauer P6 (market name P225), albeit its expense ensured the P7 became the least adopted of the 3. It likewise exuded its sophistication in its outward appearance, making the P7 a favored screen complement for sophisticted German characters such as Hans Gruber in Die Hard.
Going on .45 ACP Offense
In military terms, throughout history pistols had generally been defensive rather than offensive weapons; if you wanted to assault, it was always better to count on the firepower of a rifle (or, if the situation called for it, a submachine gun or shotgun). The changing nature of special operations, particularly countering terrorism, in the later Cold War prompted examination of firepower balance gaps that could be filled by new types of M1 Carbine-like personal defense weapons (a category for which H&K developed the MP7) and pistols that, while so large as to necessitate carry by external holster, were sufficient to break out of the traditional defensive role to serve as an offensive weapon. The firepower factor is also why there was the distinctly American stipulation that this offensive pistol be chambered in the heavier .45 ACP instead of NATO standard 9x19mm Parabellum (.40 S&W may have had a chance for consideration except that it was still a few years from existing when development began).
The SOCOM Mark 2- pistol series, designating in numerical order more by coincidence than design, is a menagerie of cool selections...
Mk 22: called "Hush Puppy" for its purpose-designed suppression, a HEAVILY modified Smith & Wesson Model 39 with features successful enough to trailblaze for the succeeding Model 59 (Vietnam era)
Mk 23: .45 ACP "offensive" platform designed for use with suppressor and laser aiming module (1991)
Mk 24: originally predecessor to the Mk 25 with a more proprietary feature set, the designation was later filled by the HK45C Tactical as a compact companion to the Mk 23 (2006)
Mk 25: SIG Sauer P226 with a military-grade feature set (1989)
Mk 26: Glock 26 for concealed carry (may have replaced SIG Sauer P239 in this role)
Mk 27: Glock 19, present SOCOM alternative to standard issue M17 & M18 (SIG Sauer P320)

As any fan knows, the Mark 23 project yielded not just a superb .45 ACP platform like nothing else, but a family of tough-as-nails German handguns that, thanks to a little strategic (or is it tactical?) media influx, became as associated with counter-terrorism as H&K's already famous MP5: the USP, translating to "Universal Service Pistol," making no secret the design intent. Other than expense (a considerable amount), the only real differences between the Mark 23 and USP in .45 is weight & barrel length, the Mark 23 being much bigger as it was designed as for offense. Granted both are essentially the same, and for the big tie-in to Tom Clancy's Rainbow Six (more-or-less sponsored by Heckler & Koch, considering the only non-H&K weapons equippable in the game are those that were standard US military issue at the time) the USP and Mark 23 used identical weapon models. The Mark 23 was designed for .45 ACP, however the USP was built to handle .40 S&W which made its more popular 9x19mm chambering (adopted by Germany as the P8) be all the more resilient - the USP may have been the first pistol designed from the ground up for .40, albeit SIG's P229 for the companion .357 SIG launched in 1992.
Generations from Tom Clancy to John Wick
Coincidentally it was another Tom Clancy adaptation, the film version of Clear and Present Danger, that saw the debut of the USP on film screens following its 1993 launch. The original USP, which took plastic magazines (a staple feature generally associated with Glock) in its original .40 & 9mm chamberings, took on .45 in 1995 which switched to metal magazines. For the USP Compact, launched in 1996, all calibers (including new addition .357 SIG) used metal magazines. The original USP and Compact, with matching slide profiles and use of the proprietary H&K accessory rail, make up the first generation of modern H&K pistols.

The USP family to this day (at least in 9mm & .45 chamberings) has never been fully superseded, but not for lack of trying on H&K's part. The first significant refinement (integrating lessons learned from the late 90s UMP project that failed to replace the MP5) was the P2000, which launched concurrent with the MP7 PDW and shares some elements. The P2000 improved solely on the USP Compact, even using the same magazines, but H&K's effort to supersede the full-size USP may have rested at this point on the ill-fated UCP (Universal Combat Pistol) which was Germany's attempt to match all of Belgium's 5.7x28mm efforts.
Something else the P2000 family [re]introduced with H&K's return to the concealed carry realm. Called P2000SK for the German "subcompact" moniker, the mid-size P2000 already having been slimmed down for comfortable carry it was a remarkable match. However, the polymer-framed market was becoming a crowded one at the turn of the millennium, and while H&K's offerings were noticeably higher quality that still only carried so far when Glock was more consistent and cost-effective.

The next demarcation came in 2006, with just one new member sticking to the older paradigm. The P30 reduced chambering options to .40 & 9mm, offered a SK submodel to supersede the P2000SK, and John Wick would famously show his preference for the full-size P30L. Concurrently, H&K had been consulting with American pistol experts Larry Vickers and Ken Hackathorn to design something worthy of the name that could supersede the iconic 1911, the result being the HK45. This generation was ostensibly meant to bring the entire H&K pistol catalog into the 21st century, yet the USP in .45 & 9mm holds on while the P2000 only discontinued in 2024.

In the mid-2010s came the most recent iteration which built on all prior efforts but finally crossed the line into imitation which is NOT the sincerest form of flattery. Since the time Glock scored their winner in the 1980s there have been numerous attempts to one-up them, some (like those by H&K or S&W) successful at being a better overall product but NEVER succeeding in displacing Glock as the favorite choice since its cost-effective simplicity and name-carrying reliability are a tough combination to overcome. One by one, those who originally blazed their own trails accepted the direction necessary to remain competitive and went the polymer-framed striker-fired route (Smith & Wesson with the M&P, SIG Sauer with the P320) though H&K managed to hold out longer than most others.
The curious choice to revive the Volkspistole name, though the 21st century VP family has nothing but manufacturer brand, plastic furniture and striker firing in common with the VP70, suggests being made for the everyperson despite German arms development being geared chiefly towards police and military contracts. Dimensions and standards remain remarkably close, with testimonies online that parts such as barrels from one generation can be made to work in another provided one is willing to tolerate quirks in appearance that come from using other-than-purpose-designed components. One thing that Heckler & Koch has been is supportive of its products, keeping them on the market (and in chamberings falling out of favor) for measurably longer than competition such as SIG Sauer.
The Bottom Line
And yet, despite occupying the same realm and doing them more than one better, H&K never displaced Glock as a widely favored sidearm alternative outside of Germany - despite their close relationship with the company and favoring of its long arms, Britain ended up choosing Glock as its new standard service pistol while America has only adopted for special issue a couple models in .45. In international outreach fellow German producer SIG Sauer has proven much more successful, its own "Glock clone" selected to replace the Beretta M9 as US military standard (with the Mark 25 and M11 successful as special issues for decades). As the Sommelier tells John Wick: "I know of your fondness for the German variants, but I can wholeheartedly endorse the new breed of Austrians."
Yet, anecdotally and in research terms, this author has never once observed criticism of how WELL H&K pistols just work. Polymer frames have considerations that make them not suitable for just anyone, but if that is the direction to go in it is difficult to find better than a built-like-a-Leopard-tank HK. It is true that they are expensive, but unilateral word from those who took the plunge is that they are 100% WORTH IT, and when it comes to the personal defense realm (where the logistics of mass acquisition is not a factor) that is as ringing an endorsement as there can be.





Comments